US colleges that consider test scores generally accept both the SAT and the ACT. To choose, take an official full-length practice test of each under timed conditions, compare your results and how comfortable you felt, and then commit to the one that fits better. The Digital SAT is shorter and adaptive, with a calculator throughout Math, while the ACT uses a fixed-difficulty format with English, Math and Reading, plus a Science section. The ACT has changed its format recently, including shortening the test and making Science optional, so check its current structure.

Key differences

FeatureDigital SATACT
FormatAdaptive, two sections in two modules each, taken in BluebookFixed difficulty: English, Math and Reading, with Science as a further section
LengthAbout 2 hours 14 minutesChanged recently, so check the current format
Reading styleShort passages with one question eachLonger passages with several questions
ScienceNo separate Science sectionA Science section exists; recent changes made it optional
CalculatorAllowed throughout Math, built-in Desmos availableAllowed in Math, check the current rules

A practical way to choose

  • Take one official practice test of each, under timed conditions, a week apart.
  • Compare scores using College Board and ACT concordance information, and also your stamina and pacing.
  • Check whether any of your target colleges or scholarships prefer one test.
  • Choose one and prepare for it, rather than splitting effort between both.

Other things to consider

  • Some states require or offer one test during the school day.
  • Your school may provide free practice for one of them.
  • Your strengths matter: fast readers and strong science readers may like the ACT, while students who prefer shorter passages and an adaptive test may prefer the SAT.

There is no universally better test. The best choice is the one on which you can reach your highest score with the preparation you can realistically do.

Dates, deadlines, fees and policies change, so always confirm the current details on College Board's official website and on each college's admissions page.